Is It Better to Go Fishing Alone or With a Group? (Explained!)

Fishing is the perfect excuse to allow your mind and body to explore and appreciate nature.

So, Is It Better to Go Fishing Alone or With a Group?

The answer lies in your personality. Some people are extroverted but may need to explore their introverted inner self once in a while. Others prefer going in groups for companionship and safety should anything happen out of the blue.

In this guide, you will discover the pros and cons of fishing alone or with a group.

Fishing Alone VS With A Group: Which Is Right For You?

The Pros Of Fishing Alone

1. Few Distractions

There is something about solitude that makes you feel special.

You don’t want anyone distracting you from pursuing what you love.

Imagine going with friends only to realize they aren’t as interested in fishing, leave alone sightseeing like you.

What’s worse is having a friend who’s not physically fit to go on a hike, messing up the fun.

While the camaraderie spirit is what sparks the fun in fishing, in the real sense, you’re better off going alone.

You don’t want someone to complain or talk nonstop, yet all you want is serenity.

Going fishing alone is an excellent way of escaping the stress you’ve endured throughout the week.

You don’t have to feel guilty when your fishing friend suggests to tag alone when all you need is to savor the fading daylight alone.

2. Solo Fishing Can Be A Better Experience

Did you know that most fishing locations provide little support for cell phone coverage?

It’s your day to unwind, so the last thing you need is someone jamming your cell phone with calls.

Being alone with the trout is the ultimate way of perceiving the experience better.

At least going solo gives you the chance to put your fishing skills against nature without any help.

After the end of the day, the excitement can’t be compared to the distractions that second or third parties will bring.

3. The Chance To Experiment

With solo fishing, no one is around to dissuade you from experimenting.

It gives you the chance to try new techniques.

For example, you’ve never tested your abilities in casting with various bait rigs and lures.

Solo fishing provides you the opportunity to try it for the first time.

No one is around to criticize or make jokes about your inexperience.

Instead, you will only have yourself to blame, and no one will be around to witness the disappointment.

4. Fish As Long As You Want

Going fishing with your kids is an excellent way of instilling a nature-loving spirit.

However, tagging them can be mentally draining because they have a low attention span.

One minute they are all jolly and eager to catch fish, while they begin to throw tantrums after realizing it isn’t as easy as what they’ve seen in movies.

With kids, the clock is always ticking. If they’re not complaining of hunger, they want to go to the bathroom or feel wet.

Even if you have to bring them along, do it once in a while when they are less prone to fussiness.

The Con Of Fishing Alone

1. You’re On Your Own If There’s Trouble

Unless there are patrol agents or tour guides, it’s improbable that you will get the help you need when you risk an injury.

You might have a life jacket and first-aid kit for such emergencies.

However, improper handling of fishing hooks and rods puts you at a higher risk of injury.

Then, there are possibilities of a giant of hex flies attacking, mainly if you’re fishing in a remote waterbody like in Northern Michigan.

When you’re in the company of two or more people, it’s easier for them to save you than when you’re alone.

emember, your safety comes first and if that means tagging along with a friend, do it.

Pros Of Group Fishing

1. Teamwork Makes The Dream Work

Nothing beats the power of team culture, which explains why going fishing with a group.

You have tales to tell at the end of your trip, regardless of the experiences you had.

Additionally, you have at least one or two people teaching you some angling tricks you never knew.

Also, your chances of catching bigger fish are higher, and you can enjoy it for dinner while you unwind.

2. Time With Loved Ones

Fishing isn’t all about who is experienced and who is not. It’s all about luck, instead.

When you join hands to catch fish, your bond becomes more assertive.

For starters, it prepares you to watch out for each other. You have someone willing to talk by your side, a strategy that helps teams communicate better.

Plus, there’s always someone to take pictures to create special memories.

3. You Have Backup If Trouble Occurs

Accidents happen all the time, even with fishing professionals. Some studies suggest that more than 80% of anglers park near the water to avoid hiking.

A slight mistake makes anyone prone to personal injuries and other mishaps.

The difference between teamwork and solo fishing is the promptness to offer help when needed.

For example, if you accidentally slip down a hill and sprain your ankle, a member of your team can walk you to the car.

Moreover, they can nurse your injuries through first-aid before taking you to a hospital.

The Cons Of Group Fishing

1. Everything It Out OF Your Control

As long as you have company, nothing is yours to control.

Either you consult each other, or no one gets the privilege to run things.

For example, if you want to fish in a particular place, you will first tell your colleagues about it. Chances are, some might not be comfortable with the idea.

Also, there is the element of fallouts if one person doesn’t agree with the rest. At least when you’re alone, you can decide how and where to go.

2. Lack Of Privacy

The solitude and the need for privacy don’t necessarily amount to selfishness.

Sometimes, you want to be alone for your peace of mind, but you can’t have it when you have company.

The sad part about group fishing is the possibility of someone embarrassing you for not catching a fish.

Furthermore, there is always someone insisting they’re perfect, so they won’t let you have your way.

Again, back and forth arguments regarding fishing techniques and the equipment to carry can lead to fallouts which might take months or years to mend. You’re better off going alone.


Both solo and group fishing have benefits and downsides, depending on individual preferences.

If you believe fishing alone is your way of unwinding, go for it, but don’t forget that you may need a hand when you get into trouble.

Fishing as a group is also an excellent chance to bond with your loved ones, but you might not enjoy your privacy or have any right to contribute to decision-making.

Otherwise, it’s best to try both options to see which fits your personality first before coming up with your verdict.


The Perils of Fishing Alone or Why You Should With a Guide or a Friend

The Joys of Fishing Alone Safely